Why Is the U.S. So Good at Nation-Breaking And So Poor at Nation-Building?

Air Force photo by Senior Airman Nichelle Anderson
Air Force photo by Senior Airman Nichelle Anderson
The U.S. military drops humanitarian goods to the Yap islands of Micronesia

As the colors are cased in Baghdad on Thursday, and U.S. military says its goodbyes, Iraq remains a nation with large, gaping wounds nearly a decade after the U.S. invaded. While the U.S. military remains the world’s best at breaking countries, it doesn’t do so well in what the Pentagon calls “Phase IV ops” – putting them back together again. Is this a flaw in our national DNA (“Do Not Attempt”)? Is it because it’s too hard to do? Too costly? Over at Small Wars Journal,  Army officers Brian M. Michelson and Sean P. Walsh sum it up:

Our national ability to conduct timely reconstruction and stabilization operations remains anemic due to our limited ability to project “civilian power,” the full, non-military capabilities of our nation in a “Whole of Government” manner. We will remain so until we respond to the fundamental changes demanded during this era of persistent conflict by providing our interagency community with a legislated mandate for change, the resources to achieve the mandate, and accountability for progress. Should we continue to embrace the status quo, we will not only jeopardize our ability to achieve the aims of our current National Security Strategy, but continue to risk additional blood and treasure in future conflicts.

Full article here.

Related Topics: Afghanistan, Development, Iraq, Military, National Security, Pentagon, Politics, State Department
  • Latest on Battleland

    Getty

    Trash Talk…

    Trash can be deadly. You can get a hint of that from the contract solicitation issued Tuesday by the Defense Logistics Agency’s European disposition office seeking “hazardous waste services in southwest Asia.”

    Army photo / Sgt. Michael J. MacLeod

    Firefight Along Highway 1

    Reuters

    Americans Choose Up Sides — Japan Over China

    TOKYO – Maybe it’s sympathy from last year’s triple disasters or maybe it’s just China being China. But for what it’s worth, Americans increasingly view Japan as its most important ally in Asia.

blog comments powered by Disqus