Happy Birthday, War

It was nine years ago today that the U.S. launched its war on Afghanistan in retaliation for the 9/11 terror attacks that killed nearly 3,000 Americans. Here’s a graf from a file I wrote on the eve of the conflict:

As Pentagon planners chart their next moves into Afghanistan, U.S. special forces have a big decision to make. If they are lucky enough to apprehend Osama bin Laden in his mountain lair, will they opt for a “snatch-and-grab” mission, tossing him, alive, into a helicopter, to face justice? Or will they simply “blow-and-go,” killing him on the spot or, preferably, turning him over to Afghans for the coup de grace? “Our guys are going to be in the killing business in Afghanistan,” says an Army special forces veteran. “When you’re fighting people who desire to die for their cause, you accommodate them as quickly as possible.”

Well, as they say, no war plan survives contact with the enemy. The war enters its 10th year today. Two thousand, one hundred and thirty-one allied troops — including 1,321 Americans — have perished, as have untold numbers of Afghans. U.S. taxpayers have spent $350 billion on the  war to date, and continue to spend about $6 billion a month there — nearly $10 million an hour. Debate over the wisdom of the conflict — and how to fight it — persist. Remember: the war’s initial goal was to topple the Taliban, which the U.S. and its allies achieved by the end of 2001. The early sense of quagmire was replaced by victory, only to be followed by another quagmire, in which we are currently about chest-high.

George Soros’ liberal Open Source Foundations are releasing a poll today that they claim shows the Afghan people’s trust in the war effort is eroding. “Failure to understand and respond to Afghan anger over the conduct of international forces and broader international community policies has led to ill-informed policy-making that has not been as effective as possible, or worse, has exacerbated existing problems,” the group says. “Many Afghans interviewed not only regarded the international community with suspicion, many accused internationals, and the international military in particular, of directly or indirectly supporting insurgents in order to justify their continued presence in Afghanistan.” While Afghan doubts may be growing, it’s also true that there have been many polls  showing most Afghans despise the Taliban.

Meanwhile, back on Capitol Hill, the senior Republican on the House Armed Services Committee sent a letter to the Pentagon yesterday wondering if President Obama will consider sending more U.S. troops into the fight. The perception that Obama has imposed a troop ceiling — and that we have reached it — “may have hampered the ability of commanders to deploy needed capabilities,” Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, R-Calif., wrote to Michelle Flournoy, the Pentagon’s No. 3 official. He asks for clarification.

You may now blow out the candles.

Related Topics: National Security
  • Latest on Battleland

    Army photo / Sgt. Michael J. MacLeod

    Humpin’ It…And Jammin’ It…

    Reuters

    China’s ‘Security Dilemma’ Risks Arms Race in Asia

    TOKYO – A shooting war with China may not be inevitable, but a dangerous arms escalation seems a dead certainty. That’s the take from a rare public discussion here this week among naval experts from Japan, the U.S. and China.

    Chris Hondros / Getty Images

    Mental Ills Top Reason U.S. Troops Now Hospitalized

    Four of the top five non-combat medical conditions sending troops to the hospital in 2011 were mental ailments, the Pentagon reports:

  • newfreedomblog

    “U.S. taxpayers have spent $350 billion on the war to date, and continue to spend about $6 billion a month there — nearly $10 million an hour.”

    .
    This says it all. In a war which has been un-winnable from the get-go, spending like this is nothing short of ridiculous.
    .
    It is time to end this. Bring our troops home. Home from every outpost around the world. Let Europe fend for themselves. Put our troops to work at home defending our borders, ports, and air terminals. This would solve many problems we currently have here at home.

  • http://forgottenlord.livejournal.com forgottenlord

    11 candles? What are the extra two for?

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    While Afghan doubts may be growing, it’s also true that there have been many polls showing most Afghans despise the Taliban.
    .
    That is why I get so disgusted when the talk turns to the rules of engagment and complaints about “our hands being tied”
    .
    The fact that vast tracts of America still think the war is against Islam and fail to understand that the mission is to protect our Muslim allies from our Muslim enemies is a monumental tragedy.
    .
    Whether our effort are helping or hurting is a separate question, but anyone who thinks that the solution is more killing is just in it for the rush.

  • nflfoghorn

    We’re CELEBRATING this???

  • destor23

    You say the initial goal was the topple the Taliban. If that’s true, the initial goal was the mistake that caused the quagmire.

    I thought the initial goal was to kill or capture bin Laden and to disrupt al-Qaeda. The Taliban was simply in the way.

    I think the conflation of the Taliban with al-Qaeda, which happened very quickly and was perhaps inevitable, is the cause of many of our problems.

    The Taliban was a government. Whether it stood or fell should not have mattered to us. Only getting bin Laden and his top people should have mattered. The Taliban could then have been isolated and starved with sanctions until it fell on its own.

    After 9/11 what I wanted, and what I think most Americans wanted, was the perpetrators to be brought to justice, not a war that wound up killing more Americans than the act that precipitated it.

  • nflfoghorn

    Life after Tora Bora: It’s OK, he’s outta our hair…let’s go bomb Iraq.
    .
    If we hadn’t been LIED TO by W and Dick (using Powell as a sort of emetic proxy) we would’ve concentrated only on Afghanistan and gotten who we’re still apparently looking for. And been out in two years, tops.

  • http://phd9.blogspot.com Paul Dirks

    Don’t forget that Kerry campaigned on “the wrong war at the wrong time” America nevertheless chose to “stay the course” for four more years.

  • sartreshockey

    Nearly 3,000 people died on September 11, true, but it’s inaccurate to say nearly 3,000 Americans did. About 2,700 Americans died; 372 of the victims were foreign nationals. It’s not an insignificant number—that’s over 12 percent of the total number of people who perished at the hands of terrorism that day.
    .
    Besides, it’s not just about the math. The rhetoric of “3,000 Americans died” versus “3,000 people from over 50 nations” or even “2,700 Americans and hundreds more from around the world” is pretty starkly different.

  • michaelfury

    “in retaliation for the 9/11 terror attacks that killed nearly 3,000 Americans”

    http://michaelfury.wordpress.com/2010/10/06/were-not-safe/

  • 11charlie

    “The perception that Obama has imposed a troop ceiling — and that we have reached it — ‘may have hampered the ability of commanders to deploy needed capabilities,’ Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, R-Calif., wrote to Michelle Flournoy, the Pentagon’s No. 3 official. He asks for clarification.”
    .
    You mean troops that have already two or three tours? I wish I could remember the source, but several years ago I read a medical report that said the current US military have experienced the greatest level of stress, both from combat and from the constan deployments, than in any other conflict in American history.
    .
    There’s only so much that our men and women in uniform can take.

  • textee

    Obama, Holder, Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, the racist, self-described “Wise Latina”, the military hating radical Kagan and probably Anthony Kennedy, think that a federal judge must sign a warrant prior to the United States military even before the military considers approaching bin Laden.

  • http://patricksartor.wordpress.com patricksartor

    ” In a war which has been un-winnable from the get-go, spending like this is nothing short of ridiculous.”
    .
    Go back to the 1960s, hippie!
    .
    This war is needed.
    .
    I can’t believe, out of all people, you, want the US to leave Afghanistan to terrorists.

  • http://patricksartor.wordpress.com patricksartor

    Agreed.
    .
    Stabilization and civilian aid is what we need.

  • http://patricksartor.wordpress.com patricksartor

    “There’s only so much that our men and women in uniform can take.”
    .
    That’s why, nine years ago, when I was 30 years old expected and even on some level hoped for a draft letter in the mail.
    .
    Constant troop rotation is the antidote or, the means of preventing PTSD. A large number of soldiers facing, each, a few instances of combat is unlikely to cause PTSD in otherwise mentally healthy people.
    .
    Of course there was no draft and our troops were diverted to Iraq.

  • http://patricksartor.wordpress.com patricksartor

    Textee,
    .
    Please don’t use crack before posting.
    .
    You have created yet another undecipherable post.

  • http://jeustor.wordpress.com jeustor

    Mission accomplished for Mr Bush then.

    1. Invade and destroy a country.

    2. Send children to die for nothing but oil and greed. Sent to kill orbe killed in 8 years of war in 2 countries. Over 8,000 coalition soldiers dead. Support you troops, don’t start an UNNECESSARY WAR and
    send them to die.

    3. Murder innocent human beings, steal their oil and culture. Create a war ravaged country of confused people, wondering why exactly they were
    invaded and what exactly they needed to be freed from.

    4. Destroy a nation and rob them of their tax money. Make the people of that nation all accomplices to murder and the target for a devastating karmic backlash for allowing you free rain to murder in their name. (go US of A!!)

    5. Revert money that should have gone to social programs, job growth and the betterment of a nation to war mongrels and makers of weapons of mass destruction.His friends and bed fellows…

    6. Walk away a free man, reaping the rewards of robbing a nation and Satan’s blessings for handing over the souls of the American people to Satan as payment for his murderous rampage (he’s a self proclaimed WAR
    president!!)

    7. Buy property in Central and South America for continued exploitation of tribal cultures, all using American Tax payer monies and live comfortably until dead.

    Job well done Mr Bush. Satan luvs you and can’t wait for you to join him in hell….

    And thank you Mr Obama, for standing aside and doing nothing as BUSH walked away a free man. Good job in taking over where he left off…yeah, the boys are back home…the ones that weren’t killed that is.

  • apr2563

    Newrusty: We agree. TaDa!

  • apr2563

    Of course, I would offer save haven to all Afghan women and children and provide means to evacuate them.

  • apr2563

    Correction: “safe” haven

blog comments powered by Disqus